By Radhika Bombaywala
Listen to this submission by clicking play below!
As an international student stepping into the academic culture of the United States, the experience was bewildering. Back home, where our pens flowed with ink and diligence on paper, and Google was a solitary beacon in the search for knowledge, the transition to the US educational system felt like a leap into the unknown. The maze of formatting styles like APA and MLA was just the tip of the iceberg. In response to my concern about adhering to citation guidelines and navigating the complexities of academic writing, my advisor at Penn State suggested using digital tools like, AI paraphrasers. I was perplexed. I pondered, “Isn’t this akin to cheating?” as the notion of relying on technology to articulate my thoughts was unfamiliar territory.
Yet, a gradual introduction to digital aids began to dismantle my initial skepticism, and my freshman year unfolded with fewer hurdles than I’d braced for.
My immersion into the digital academic landscape became particularly pronounced in one of my ESL classes—the foundational English course every international student is expected to undertake. In this class, a surprising directive came from the professor themselves. They actively encouraged us to employ various digital tools, including paraphrasing software, to polish our essays. This approach was not about compromising academic integrity but about enhancing the clarity and presentation of our work. It reflected a pragmatic acknowledgment that the end goal was effective communication, and these tools could be instrumental in achieving that. This instructor’s encouragement demonstrated a progressive approach to teaching, prioritizing effective communication over traditional methods.
The true game-changer, however, arrived in my sophomore year with ChatGPT. The once arduous process of crafting essays and reports transformed into a streamlined task, accomplished with a few keystrokes. This simplicity was seductive, but it also kindled a debate within me: Is ChatGPT a revolutionary asset or a potential peril to our intellectual evolution?
ChatGPT’s integration into every aspect of our lives, from professional environments to the educational sphere, heralds a profound transformation in our approach to writing and ideation. On the bright side, it levels the playing field, offering students from diverse educational backgrounds a means to bridge gaps seamlessly. Yet, it also compels us to question its impact on our creative faculties and the intrinsic value of original thought.
Amidst this simplicity and efficiency lies a potential compromise—could we be forfeiting critical thinking and personal endeavor for convenience? The academic realm, a former bastion of unique insights and meticulous research, is at risk of becoming a domain where technological prowess supersedes intellectual rigor. Similarly, in the professional world, industries that once prided themselves on the specialized skills of writers and editors are now encountering an era where AI can churn out comparable work in mere moments. This shift is not only a marvel of technological progress; it is a clarion call to reevaluate our connection with creativity and intellectual labor.
In the heart of the writing center, a question lingers in the air: Should writing tutors recommend digital tools like ChatGPT to students seeking assistance? It is a question that invites us to consider the evolving responsibilities of educators in the age of information and artificial intelligence.
Writing centers have long stood as bastions of academic support, offering a sanctuary where students can develop their writing skills under the guidance of experienced tutors. These tutors have traditionally focused on teaching the fundamentals—grammar, structure, and clarity. However, as the digital landscape encroaches upon traditional educational practices, the tutors’ roles are inevitably shifting. They are now at the forefront of a new educational frontier, where the fusion of technology and teaching requires a delicate balance.
The argument for incorporating AI tools in writing tutoring is compelling. These tools can offer instantaneous feedback, a wider array of phrasing options, and even insights into the organization of complex thoughts. They can act as a catalyst for learning, sparking discussions on why one expression works better than another, or how a particular sentence structure enhances the flow of an argument. In this light, recommending such tools can be seen as an extension of the tutors’ pedagogical toolkit, providing a multifaceted learning experience that marries the best of human insight with the precision of technology.
Standing at this juncture, it is crucial to cultivate a balanced view.
If we harness ChatGPT as an enhancer of our abilities rather than a substitute, we might forge a future where technology and human creativity coexist in synergy. The educational system, especially, has a critical role in steering this course by integrating digital tools in a way that enriches, rather than eclipses, conventional learning.
Reflecting on my own evolution from a bewildered newcomer to a proficient user of digital academic tools, I recall a pivotal moment at the university writing center. It was during a tutorial session when I hesitated to utilize ChatGPT and similar AI tools. My mentor, sensing my uncertainty, shared a poignant memory of their initial encounter with ChatGPT. They vividly described how it transformed their perspective on the role of AI in writing. This story resonated deeply with me, highlighting the potential of AI to enhance rather than replace the writer’s voice. It emphasized the importance of authenticity and maintaining the integrity of our work, even when leveraging technological advancements. As I continue to navigate this evolving landscape and witness the discourse surrounding AI tools like ChatGPT, I am reminded of the value of staying true to one’s voice while embracing the possibilities offered by technology.
ChatGPT, in all its brilliance, mirrors our collective hopes and fears in the digital age. It provokes us to reconsider the essence of education, creativity, and labor in a world where AI is an extension of human intellect. The journey of a perplexed international student using AI to grow into a savvy digital academic is a microcosm of a larger discourse on technology’s role in shaping our intellectual and professional futures. ChatGPT is not just a tool; it is a testament to the dynamic alliance between humans and machines.
About the Author
Radhika Bombaywala is currently a junior, pursuing a major in Advertising & Public Relations, complemented by minors in Business Studies and Digital Media Trend Analytics. Set to graduate in 2025, Radhika’s academic journey is augmented by her role as a tutor at the writing center, showcasing her dedication to fostering effective communication. A fun fact about Radhika is that she is allergic to bananas.